Still Austin Order of Nancy Single Barrel Oated Bourbon Review
A Rare Selection Bourbon from Austin, Texas
Still Austin has built a reputation for doing things differently in the Texas whiskey scene, and the Order of Nancy Rare Selection Single Barrel is a perfect example of that philosophy in liquid form. Picked by members of Still Austin’s Order of Nancy, this malted oated straight bourbon whiskey leans into texture, spice, and structure rather than traditional sweetness.
Bottled at a bold 125.86 proof and aged at least five years, this release showcases how thoughtful mashbills and patient aging can create something that stands apart in modern Texas whiskey.
The Story Behind Order of Nancy
The Order of Nancy (OON) is Still Austin’s quietly legendary membership group, made up of some of the brand’s most dedicated fans. Members get access to exclusive events, barrel selections, and limited releases that rarely make it beyond the distillery walls.
This particular single barrel was selected by Order of Nancy members for Order of Nancy members, making it a deeply personal expression of Still Austin’s identity in Austin, Texas. It’s not a mass-appeal bourbon, and it doesn’t try to be. It’s a bottle chosen by people who already understand what Still Austin does best.
Mashbill & Specs
Distillery: Still Austin Whiskey Co.
Release: Rare Selection Single Barrel – Order of Nancy
Style: Malted Oated Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Proof: 125.86
Age: At least 5 years
Mashbill:
58% Texas White Corn
35% Naked Oats
7% Wildfire Malted Barley
Price: $90
This mashbill alone signals that this won’t be a traditional Texas bourbon experience. The heavy oat content plays a huge role in both flavor and mouthfeel.
Nose
The nose is immediately intriguing. There’s a sharp, green spiciness that almost reads as rye at first, even though there’s no rye present. Fresh green bell pepper dominates, joined by a touch of jalapeño and a light vegetal crispness. With time, a faint hint of cinnamon emerges, but the profile stays focused and clean rather than layered and sweet.
This isn’t a dense or sugary nose. It’s restrained, fresh, and slightly savory, setting expectations for what’s to come.
Palate
The palate closely follows the nose. Green bell pepper shows up right away, with jalapeño heat softened into something closer to jalapeño jam than raw spice. Subtle notes of vanilla and caramel appear, but they remain background players rather than the main attraction.
The oats contribute a rounded texture that keeps the high proof from feeling aggressive. As the sip develops, sweet cinnamon emerges, carrying through into a long, wet, and spicy finish that lingers pleasantly.
Finish
Long, warming, and gently spicy. Cinnamon and green pepper notes hang around well after the sip, with just enough sweetness to keep things balanced. It’s a finish that invites another pour rather than demanding one.
Final Thoughts
This Still Austin Order of Nancy single barrel is not trying to be universally approachable, and that’s exactly why it works. It lives in an interesting space between savory and sweet, leaning heavily into green, vegetal flavors without ever becoming off-putting.
It’s the kind of Texas whiskey that makes you think about pairing possibilities rather than dessert clichés. Fresh vegetables, good cheese, and a solid French onion dip wouldn’t feel out of place next to this pour.
Would I buy another bottle if given the chance? Absolutely. It’s distinctive, well-executed, and unapologetically itself. And in a crowded bourbon market, that counts for a lot, especially coming out of Austin, Texas.
Texas Whiskey Geek is built for—and supported by—the Texas whiskey community.
Merch sales help keep the site running, completely ad-free, and independent, which means I can keep spotlighting Texas distilleries, events, and releases without outside noise. If you feel like repping Texas whiskey, checking out the merch is a great way to support the site.
